If we’re fine saying “Halloween”, we should be fine saying “Christmas”

Question time.

What Christian holiday resulted from the Roman Catholic Church co-opting a pagan festival that marked the beginning of winter?

Christmas, you say? No—Halloween. That’s right, Halloween is a contracted form of “All Hallows’ Eve,” a Catholic holiday that was moved by the Church from mid-May to October 31 in the 8th century AD to appropriate an existing Celtic pagan holiday called Samhain, which marked the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter.

“Halloween” is yet another Christianized version of a pre-Christian European pagan holiday.

With all the controversy about renaming Christmas trees to “holiday trees” or Christmas parties to “holiday parties” because Christmas is “solely for Christians,” why don’t we see any of this renaming occurring for Halloween-related things? Why does the secular world at large use a Roman Catholic-derived term to denote supposedly secular holiday activities?

Of course, Halloween in modern practice has virtually no associations with the Church whatsoever, although the day that follows it (All Hallows’ Day) still remains a religious holiday celebrated by Western Christians the world over. The only difference between Halloween and Christmas is that Christianity at large has rejected the modern secularized version of the former, but embraced the secularized version of the latter.

Why should we let Christian religious observances or lack thereof of any particular holiday dictate whether we are willing to use terms with Christian etymology? If a group of neopagans started worshipping Thursday because it was named for Thor, would that result in the society at large referring to that day as “Deityday” to avoid any association with their religious observance?

Food for thought. Please share your comments below.

Oh, and Happy Halloween (or happy late-October holiday season to those who are not Roman Catholics or Celtic pagans)!


One thought on “If we’re fine saying “Halloween”, we should be fine saying “Christmas”

  1. Thank you, thank you!! I’m tired of explaining that the word ‘Christmas’ has become completely secularized, as far as I’m concerned, and that I (as an agnostic.. formerly an atheist with pagan leanings) am disturbed by attempts to abolish, in a very scary _1984_ sort of way, the very name of this hugely significant European historical/cultural celebration. I’m amused that Buddhist/Christian/Shinto/atheist/etc. Japanese people, for instance, tend not to be bothered by the word ‘Kurisumasu,’ or being wished a ‘Merii Kurisumasu.’ What is going on here?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s